FWGNA > Species Accounts > Pleuroceridae > Pleurocera troostiana edgariana
Pleurocera troostiana edgariana (Lea 1841)
Goniobasis or "Elimia" edgariana
  • click to view larger

> Habitat & Distribution

The range of Pleurocera troostiana (sl), together with all its probable variants, subspecies and synonyms, extends from the Valley-and-Ridge province of SW Virginia and East Tennessee west through the Unglaciated Interior Low Plateau of Middle Tennessee and North Alabama, north into central Kentucky.  We have records of P. troostiana (in its broadest sense) from small streams across the entire Tennessee/Cumberland drainage into the Green and Tradewater River drainages of The Ohio.

Isaac Lea gave the habitat of his "Melania edgariana" as "Cany Fork, Tenn," certainly a mis-spelling of Caney Fork, draining north along the western slope of the Cumberland Plateau into the Cumberland River.  Goodrich (1940) broadened the range of "Goniobasis edgariana" to "streams of Cumberland, Duck and Elk Rivers, Tennessee."  We have records of edgariana (now understood as a subspecies of P. troostiana) throughout the Cumberland drainage of TN/KY, including the Stones, Harpeth, and Obey as well as the Caney/Collins river system.  The range of P. troostiana edgariana also includes many tributaries of The Tennessee, including the Elk River of North Alabama and the Duck River of Middle Tennessee

Within this region populations primarily inhabit small, rich, hardwater creeks, although ranging out into larger rivers when cool and clear.  They even inhabit some cooler and clearer reservoirs, such as Center Hill Lake.  The FWGNA incidence rank of all four P. troostiana subspecies considered together is I-5.
  

> Ecology & Life History

Bickel (1968) offered a very complete description of the habitat of central Kentucky P. troostiana populations (subspecies lyonii), which he said were "commonly found on firm surfaces in riffle areas but more abundant in shallow spots near shore where water is in motion although slow moving and less turbulent."  That is a good description of the habitat of many P. troostiana edgariana populations as well.  We should also add that edgariana populations can inhabit the sandy/cobbly shallows of cool reservoirs, below the winter draw-down level.

Bickel also focused a great deal of attention on egg masses, which he figured and described as "plano-convex, 1.3 - 2.0 mm in diameter, and partly covered with fine sand grains."  He personally observed eggs "deposited on the undersides of stones" in the month of April, but quoted an unpublished Ph.D. dissertation by W. L. Minkley to the effect that egg masses could be found "July through September, as well as during October, January, and April."

Alas, Bickel did not offer any further observations on life history.  But it seems reasonable to expect that two years will be required for maturity, and that several years of iteroparous reproduction can be expected thereafter, as is the case for pleurocerids generally (Dazo 1965). This is life cycle Hi of Dillon (2000: 156 - 162). 

> Taxonomy & Systematics

In some of our prior publications (Stewart & Dillon 2004, Dillon & Robinson 2007a) as well as in previous versions of this website, we referred to this species as Pleurocera (or Goniobasis) arachnoidea (Anthony, 1854) - the oldest name available in the Virginia literature.  The extension of the FWGNA survey into east Tennessee, however, uncovered a great number of synonyms for this species with earlier dates than Anthony's arachnoidea, including Isaac Lea's troostiana, to which we ultimately awarded the blue ribbon. 

There is much confusion on the precise date of Lea's authorship of Melania troostiana, however - Burch (1989) and Graf (2001) giving 1838 and Tryon (1873) and Goodrich (1940) giving 1841.  Lea apparently read his paper describing troostiana before the American Philosophical Society on November 4, 1836, Scudder (1885) asserts that Volume 6 of the Transactions (in which Lea's description was published) was printed and ready for publication in 1838, and the date on the front cover of Transactions Volume 6 (in which his description was published) states "1839."   For a more complete discussion see my essay of 6Dec19 from the link below.

Three populations of P. troostiana (identified as G. arachnoidea) were included in the allozyme study of Dillon & Robinson (2007a).  The species is quite distinct genetically.  There is no evidence of hybridization with either P. simplex or P. clavaeformis, two other species of Pleurocera with which it often co-occurs in the East.

As the FWGNA project expanded into Middle Tennessee, North Alabama, and Kentucky, however, we discovered that populations of P. troostiana inhabiting streams west of Walden Ridge at Chattanooga often bear shells that are costate as well as striate.  The appearance of costae on the shells of P. troostiana corresponds strikingly with the distribution of Pleurocera laqueata, a costate species which ranges as far east as Walden Ridge but no further.  The reason for this abrupt discontinuity is not clear, but the hypothesis that P. troostiana may hybridize with P. laqueata in Middle Tennessee is inescapable.  

So for the variably-striate (but uncostate) populations of East Tennessee we suggest retaining the typical nomen Pleurocera troostiana troostiana.  For populations bearing lightly costate shells we suggest P. troostiana perstriata, for those bearing heavily costate shells P. troostiana edgariana, and for the variably-shelled populations inhabiting Ohio drainages of central Kentucky P. troostiana lyonii.  A complete review of the elaborate taxonomy of Pleurocera troostiana is available as a download here [pdf].

Originally described in the genus Melania, Tryon (1873) transferred edgariana to Goniobasis and synonymized it under G. nassula (Conrad 1834).  Goodrich (1940) resurrected the nomen out from under synonymy and listed 13 synonyms underneath it.  Burch transferred edgariana from Goniobasis to "Elimia," but otherwise transmitted the Goodrich system uncritically.  We demoted edgariana to subspecific status under troostiana in our essay of 5June20.    

This species has travelled through three genera in thirty years.  Although predominantly assigned to Goniobasis through most of the 20th century, in the 1980s many workers began placing it in the resurrected generic nomen, "Elimia."  Both Goniobasis and Elimia were subsumed under Pleurocera by Dillon (2011).  See my essay of 23Mar11 from the link below for more.

> Maps and Supplementary Resources


> Essays

  • Taxonomic controversy has surrounded the generic nomina Pleurocera, Goniobasis, and Elimia for many years.  The best entry into the subject would be my essay of 23Mar11, entitled Goodbye Goniobasis, Farewell Elimia.  Links are available from that essay to older resources.
  • In my blog post of 4Aug19, "CPP Diary: Yankees at The Gap," I documented a striking case of cryptic phenotypic plasticity in the population of P. troostiana inhabiting a little stream that runs south out of Cumberland Gap, TN.
  • I used the Melania troostiana situation as an example of why Isaac Lea Drives Me Nuts in November of 2019.
  • The evidence that troostiana is the oldest available name for this entire far-flung and variable species was reviewed in 6Dec19, On the Trail of Professor Troost.  And I reviewed the evidence that seven other East Tennessee nomina should be considered its junior synonyms in my post of 7Jan20, CPP Diary: The Many Faces of Professor Troost
  • I proposed and justified the (predomiantly Cumberlandian) subspecies edgariana in my essay of 5June20, What is Melania edgariana.  See that essay for a more detailed discussion of the ecology, evolution, and systematics of this enigmatic taxon.
  • The other subspecies perstriata and lyonii were proposed in my essays of 15Apr20 Huntsville Hunt, and 6July20, The Return of Captain Lyon, respectively.

> References

Bickel, D.  (1968)  Goniobasis curreyana lyoni, a pleurocerid snail of west-central Kentucky. The Nautilus 82: 13 - 18.
Branson, B.A. (1987)  Keys to the aquatic gastropoda known from Kentucky.  Trans. Kentucky Acad. Sci. 48: 11 - 19.
Burch, J. B. (1989)  North American Freshwater Snails.  Malacological Publications, Hamburg, Michigan.  365 pp.
Dazo, B. C. (1965)
The morphology and natural history of Pleurocera acuta and Goniobasis livescens (Gastropoda: Cerithiacea: Pleuroceridae). Malacologia 3: 1 - 80. 
Dillon, R. T., Jr. (1989)  Karyotypic evolution in pleurocerid snails: I. Genomic DNA estimated by flow cytometry. Malacologia, 31: 197-203.  
Dillon, R. T., Jr. (2000)  The Ecology of Freshwater Molluscs. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.  509 pp.  
Dillon, R. T., Jr. (2011)  Robust shell phenotype is a local response to stream size in the genus Pleurocera (Rafinesque, 1818).  Malacologia 53: 265-277.
Dillon, R. T. Jr., & K. B. Davis (1991)  The diatoms ingested by freshwater snails: temporal, spatial, and interspecific variation. Hydrobiologia 210: 233-242.   
Dillon, R. T., Jr., & J. D. Robinson (2007a) The Goniobasis ("Elimia") of southwest Virginia, I. Population genetic survey.  Report to the Virginia Division of Game & Inland Fisheries, 25 pp.  [PDF]
Goodrich, C. (1913)  Spring collecting in southwest Virginia.  Nautilus 27: 81-82, 91-95.
Goodrich, C. (1935)  Studies of the gastropod family Pleuroceridae V.  Occas. Pprs. Mus. Zool. Univ. Mich., 318: 1 - 12. 
Goodrich, C. (1940) The Pleuroceridae of the Ohio River drainage system.  Occas. Pprs. Mus. Zool. Univ. Mich., 417: 1-21.
Graf, D. L. (2001)  The cleansing of the Augean stables.  Walkerana 12(27): 1 - 124.
Jokinen, E.H. 1992.
The Freshwater Snails (Mollusca: Gastropoda) of New York State. NY State Mus Bull 482, Albany, New York.
Scudder, N. P. (1885)  Bibliographies of American naturalists - II. The published writings of Isaac Lea, LL.D.  Bullentin of the US National Museum 23: 1 - 278.
Smith, D.G. 1980. Goniobasis virginica (Gastropoda: Pleuroceridae) in the Connecticut River USA. Nautilus 94:50-54.
Stewart, T. W., & R. T. Dillon, Jr.  (2004)  Species composition and geographic distribution of Virginia's freshwater gastropod fauna: A review using historical records.  Am. Malac. Bull. 19: 79-91.
Tryon, G. W. (1873)  Land and Freshwater shells of North America Part IV, Strepomatidae.  Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections 253: 1 - 435.